If you’re missing several teeth, or all of them, the two most common ways to replace them are dentures and dental implants. Both can restore your smile and help you chew, but they work very differently. This comparison can help you think about what matters most to you before talking with your dentist.
How dentures work
Dentures are removable replacement teeth. A full denture replaces all the teeth in one jaw and rests on the gums, held in place by suction and the shape of your mouth. A partial denture replaces some teeth and usually clips onto the remaining natural teeth. Dentures are taken out to clean and usually left out overnight.
How implants work
A dental implant is a titanium post placed in the jawbone. Once the bone has bonded with it, a crown, bridge or denture can be attached. A single implant can replace one tooth; several implants can support a bridge or a full arch, such as with All-on-4.
Comparison
| Dentures | Implants | |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed or removable | Removable | Fixed (or clip-on overdentures) |
| Surgery | No | Yes |
| Treatment time | Weeks | Months |
| Chewing ability | Reduced, especially lower full dentures | Closer to natural teeth |
| Effect on jawbone | Bone continues to shrink | Helps preserve bone |
| Upfront cost | Lower | Higher |
| Ongoing care | Relines and replacement over time | Cleaning and regular reviews |
Advantages of dentures
- No surgery required.
- Lower upfront cost: full and partial dentures at Parramatta Dentistry range from $800 to $2,800, depending on the material. Conditions apply.
- Faster: often completed within a few weeks.
- Suitable for many people who can’t have implants for medical reasons.
- Easy to add teeth if more are lost later (for partials).
Limitations of dentures
- Can move or feel loose, especially lower full dentures.
- May affect taste and speech at first.
- Harder foods can be difficult to chew.
- The jawbone shrinks over time without tooth roots, so dentures need relining or remaking.
- Partial dentures can put extra load on the teeth they clip to.
Advantages of implants
- Fixed, so they don’t move when you eat or talk.
- Chewing is closer to natural teeth.
- Help preserve the jawbone where they’re placed.
- Don’t rely on neighbouring teeth for support.
Limitations of implants
- Surgery is required, with associated risks.
- Treatment takes months.
- Higher upfront cost. At Parramatta Dentistry, a simple single implant in a back tooth, without bone grafting, starts from $4,500 (or from $30 a week with an interest-free payment plan). Conditions apply.
- Need enough bone, or bone grafting first.
- Not everyone is suitable.
A middle option: implant-retained dentures
An overdenture clips onto two or more implants. It’s still removable for cleaning, but it’s far more stable than a conventional denture, particularly in the lower jaw. This can be a good balance of cost, stability and maintenance for some people.
Things to think about
- How important is it that your teeth are fixed rather than removable?
- Are you comfortable having surgery?
- How long can you wait for the final result?
- What’s your budget, now and over the next ten years, including maintenance?
- Do you have medical conditions that affect healing?
Risks
Implant surgery carries risks including infection, bleeding, nerve injury, sinus problems and implant failure. Dentures can cause sore spots, and poorly fitting dentures can irritate gums. Your dentist will explain the risks that apply to you.
Read more about dental implants and tooth replacement options.
Frequently asked questions
Can I switch from dentures to implants later?
Yes, many people do. However, the jawbone shrinks over time without teeth, so the longer you wait, the more likely bone grafting may be needed. Your dentist can assess your bone with a scan.
Are implant-retained dentures easier to clean than fixed implants?
Overdentures can be removed for cleaning, which some people find easier. Fixed bridges need careful cleaning underneath with special tools. Your dentist will show you how to clean whichever option you choose.
Do dentures affect taste?
Upper full dentures cover the roof of the mouth, which some people feel affects their sense of taste and temperature. Implant-supported options can sometimes reduce palate coverage.
Which option looks more natural?
Both can look natural when well made. Implants feel more like natural teeth because they’re fixed and don’t move. The result depends on careful planning and lab work.
How do I decide?
Think about stability, budget, your willingness to have surgery, healing time and maintenance. Discuss the options with your dentist, and for invasive treatment, consider seeking a second opinion.
Book at Parramatta Dentistry
Parramatta Dentistry is at Suite 25, Level 3, 27 Hunter Street, Parramatta, a short walk from Parramatta Station. We’re open Monday to Friday, 9am to 6pm, and HICAPS is on site, so you can claim from your health fund on the day and pay only the gap, if there is one. Call (02) 8090 1109 or book online.
This article is general information only and isn’t a substitute for personalised advice from your dentist. Any surgical or invasive procedure carries risks. Before proceeding, you should seek a second opinion from an appropriately qualified health practitioner.